New York hotels near Pennsylvania Station

Pros: The extra touch of getting wine and cupcakes for our anniversary. I liked that the room was ready when we checked in.

Cons: Could have used extra towels. Room keys did not work twice. Cheaper prices on mini bar . Ability to have late checkout.

Pros: Rooms were dare I say it ROOMY for NYC. Adequate storage space and closet space and bathroom was a decent size.

Cons: Thin walls, assuming our next door neighbor had to much fun at the Roof Top Bar and was throwing up the whole night, we had the pleasure of hearing every single thing for about 1-2 hours straight. Had to turn on the TV to muffle some of it out!

Pros: The staff were amazing

Pros: Relaxing vibe but still had fun energy. Our room was sooooooo quiet we didn’t even know we were in the city when we were there. Across the street is coffee culture for good coffee and Whole Foods is around the corner across from Bryant park. Close to subway which was a huge plus especially when heading to the usopen tennis.

Pros: Ten staff went above and beyond to help celebrate my birthday.

Cons: N/A

Pros: The staff was great and the hotel was just perfect

Pros: Nice place to stay, quiet , next to Times Square, good service and great bar/ restaurant .

Cons: Not enough light in the bath, over the sink.

Pros: Incredible stay at the Refinery. Came here for a surprise birthday present, and the staff were incredible. Made the surprise that muh sweeter with an upgrade and non-stop next-level service. Great hotel, rooftop, jazz, staff, rooms... all great. Will stay here again soon.

Pros: Coffee

Cons: The room was horribly small and there was no vanity room in the bathroom. Had I known it was that inadequate bi would have made other arrangements.

Pros: A good quality hotel with relaxed atmosphere. Staff helpful and professional. Excellent location for exploring Manhattan and beyond.

Cons: Over priced .... whilst happy to pay for a decent hotel, the pricing level seems high compared with other cities. Mini bar and breakfast options not used so disappointing that you feel the need to eat out.

Pros: The front desk staff was amazing!! And for a NYC hotel it doesn’t get better in size, cleanliness, etc.

Pros: Location is excellent, a couple block away from the subway. Loved the Rooftop bar with a great view of the Empire State Building

Cons: Turn down service did not provide bottled water in the room, in spite of being charged a facility fee.

Pros: Room size Checkin with Paulina Maintenance guy very friendly

Cons: Lying about property details on the phone prior to booking about essentials like black out curtains which was a precondition for us to make the booking. Staff did not want to remedy, manager on duty being rude and having way too much attitude, we suggested solutions like additional curtains but they just offered us to cut short the stay and leave (we did get refund upon insisting though) We felt we could have found a solution but the manager (Victoria I think her name was) gave us such attitude and in an absolutely unacceptable way that we didn’t have a choice but leave. Paulina at check in was very friendly though but didn’t have the power to resolve. The room condition was way below expectations and pictures are photo shopped, covering up run down room condition. AC was making loud funky sounds, upon check in we waited an hour for it to be fixed and dealt with the maintenance guy who was friendly though (after a 15h flight it was very tiring regardless and having to leave and look for a new hotel unshowered and tired and my wife pregnant was really not cool) Kimpton Not again for us for sure

Pros: Happy hour (free wine), also free bike rental. Got a room on the 21st floor looking at the empire state tower.

Cons: Everything was great.

Pros: Location was great.

Cons: Young lady at check in was not very professional... a bit snobby when answering questions, even as I was being polite and jovial... bad day or not, it's all about service and experience... Hope it improves or was a one time occurrence.

Cons: Not too customer oriented - didn’t put customer first

Pros: Great breakfast buffet and otherwise. Perfect location.

Cons: leaving!

Pros: The hotel gave us some complimentary champagne, fruit, cupcakes and water. King room and particularly the bathroom were spacious. West facing room could see the sun setting although not the nicest skyline view. Infused water available in foyer, and coffee in the morning. Also offered a drink hour in the evening.

Cons: Some areas of the room were dated. No free water bottles (aside from what was gifted later in the evening with the champagne and food). Our view wasn’t the greatest looking out to a backstreet, although my sisters upgraded room looked out 6th Avenue which was much better). Front desk could be more warm and welcoming.

Pros: It was my girlfriend and I’s anniversary, and we were greeted with champagne on ice and cupcakes by melissa in a beautiful display. We also needed some unusual things sent to the room but they were 100% accomodating. Best hotel service I’ve ever received hands down!

Cons: The only thing that could’ve been better was the wifi being free and maybe the shower/bath having some sort of view

Pros: Clean, roomy bathroom, very helpful and friendly staff and good location

Cons: No kettle or coffee machine in the room and none available in the reception except at breakfast. Tea/coffee from the bar was expensive so we went over the road to a coffee shop to get drinks. When most hotels now provide these facilities for free in the room or reception this seemed a little behind the times.

Cons: Very noisy rooms, poor shower and air con didn’t work Better hotels in NY for same price

Pros: This was one of the better stays i've ever had in NYC. The location was great, the staff was great and we upgraded to a King Room with a view and it was worth every penny and more! I will be staying here again and would recommend to anyone.

Cons: Although I know parking isn't cheap, it's one thing I wish was included in the cost of staying. However their pricing was in line with close by parking spots.

Pros: Proximity to great attractions; friendly staff; very accommodating staff..you only needed to ask for what you wanted and they were very accommodating. Great view from room.

Cons: No problems. Nothing to not like.

Pros: Liked the small sort of Kitchenette, the free and great laundrette and across the road was a great food court under the ground just to the right of Park Royal

Cons: I think it was expensive for the room as only on 3rd floor so really no view, noisy air con and room not serviced

Pros: location , staff, cleaners, I used to stay in this hotel

Cons: breakfast is not good but there are a lot of good caffe around

Pros: We loved the room as it had a separate lounge and kitchen with plenty of space. The laundry was amazing to keep up with our washing rather than a laundry. It was so clean.

Cons: Great location and close to subway, Central Park and 5th Avenue.

Pros: Brilliant location on 58th Street and the front desk team were very helpful in making sure we had a great stay and also gave us great tips for NYC. The on-site laundrette, business centre and spacious apartment were also great.

Cons: Overall very good property.

Pros: Location

Cons: The reception and coffee shop decor was dull dark and depressing and lacked character

Pros: Pricy but great location.

Pros: Awesome rooms, fabulous location one block from the park...you have the subway at your doorstep and Fifth Avenue just steps away - perfect place for a NYC trip!

Pros: Excellent location, clean, spacious and modern

Cons: Acoustic isolation from street noise, could be better.

Pros: Beautiful and comfortable property. Would love to stay again here as it is very centrally located and convenient

Pros: Modern well designed and maintained property. Great location just a block from Central Park which is a peaceful oasis in busy New York City. Complimentary access to onsite laundry with modern washers and dryers was an unexpected bonus. It was also handy having a small kitchenette with microwave in our room. The aircon worked well and the bed was super comfortable All hotel staff and cafe staff were welcoming and helpful and a pleasure to deal with.

Cons: The only minor negative is that the bathroom is very small but it is modern and well designed.

Pros: Location

Cons: Everything: rooms are disaster , stuff are completely unfriendly,

Pros: Central, convenient, good ambience, helpful staff

Cons: Building work ongoing but hopefully temporary

Pros: The bed was very comfortable. Great location and the staff is very helpful.

Pros: Location was good and staff friendly.

Cons: We came as a family of 4 in a room for 4, but we only had 3 towels.

Pros: The location is great.

Pros: It was definetly a good place to stay at. The room was very comfortable and the hotel was very well located. The hotel has a very good design and the staff is very helpful and nice.

Cons: The price is high. Can't really be helped considering the prices in NYC. We had some issues with the bathtub. It was perfect for showering but we tried having a bath and the drain would not stay completly closed.

Pros: Our second time there and it was great, certainly come back

Cons: A little bit to pricey with out breakfast

Pros: Proximity to the city but quiet

Cons: Limited options for dinner at the restaurant

Pros: Staff was wonderful - helpful in where to locate, appreciated the texting the concierge. Room was great, we had a not so great view as we were on the 3rd floor. The air conditioner was loud enough to avoid any street noise issues.

Cons: The outside of the hotel was getting worked on, would have been nice to know that prior to booking/arriving; hotel room was clean - they offered alot of extras which took up the little amount of space we had in the room - we were able to rearrange some of the food/drinks in the fridge so we could utilize all shelf space.

Pros: Bed was alright

Cons: Room was cramped, bathroom sink was clogged, maintenance appeared so/so, elevators were slow. Just didn’t get a good feel from staying here

Pros: Great staff for the most part, except for a sarcastic door man who mumbled behind my back that I should have tipped him for storing my bags (like most people I tip when I pick up, sorry dude). Clean room. I liked that I could text for extra towels and toiletries.

Cons: The breakfast buffet was the only disappointment, I paid $75 for two breakfast buffets after the taxes and fees, ridiculous price and it was almost not edible. The scrambled eggs were dripping with water, the potatoes were dried out and the selection was minimal beyond. Definitely save your money, step outside and eat better at any coffee shop for less.

Pros: The bed was very comfortable, the staff were very polit and friendly and the location was excellent.

Cons: Would have liked tea making facility in the room, there was courtesy refreshments in reception from 6am but served in unenvironmental containers.

Pros: Hotel had a really awesome location with parking in the area, and was all around a great hotel, other than our heat problem and the fact that we got charged a facility fee when we were not told anything about it prior to check in

Cons: It was 74 degrees in the room the whole night, even after a fan was put on and the window being wide open the whole night, leaving us sweating and not able to sleep a wink in the suffocating heat.

Pros: Service and view

Cons: Price

Pros: Clean and tidy. Good location.

Cons: No fridge. Our room floor was on a lean.

Pros: Love the hotel! Very classy, very clean! Wonderful staff and valet parking was great!! Beds and room clean and comfortable! I’m walking distance of EVERYTHING! 5 minute walk to Times Square!!! Wonderful place to be to see the sites and hear the sounds of NYC!!

Cons: Nothing we didn’t like! No regrets at all!

Pros: The location of the hotel was great.

Cons: I thought the front of the hotel looked horrible and I was never made aware prior to my stay. I would have chosen a nicer looking place for over $600 for 2 nights. Plus the wall paper was hanging in the bathroom. I stayed in a double room with 4 people and the room was small and there was not enough of anything for 4 people. You would think they could at least do that. Then when I went to leave I was told I had a $140.00 garage parking fee to pay that was never told to me. I believe I read online that parking was available but never mentioned a few. I was very disappointed with my stay and don't think I will return. The only thing that was told would be done was a credit for my services fees the manager provided but waiting for that refund stil. I hope something is done to compensate me. I still will pay $60 for parking I was under the impression was free.

Pros: Was ideally located

Cons: Nothing

Pros: The location and friendly staff

Cons: No toilet roll, we found a pair of dirty socks and T-shirt behind the curtains.

Pros: The location is convenient. The breakfast was very good.

Cons: I had flight delays and was supposed to arrive around 3p-4p. I ended up not getting in until 5am. I called several times to see what my options were and the staff was rude and said I could give up my room of 4 nights or pay for the night I wasn’t actually there. Ok fine. I’ll pay for 4 full nights. When I arrived I was given a room that had mold growing on the ceiling above the bed. I requested another room. I was given a temporary room and told that my room with two double beds would be reassigned to me the next day. I went down at 10am and made sure that it’s was known what my room situation was and that I would be back in the afternoon to be given keys to my new room. Came back at 4:30pm and was told that no room was approved for me because I booked through booking.com. I had to have a long conversation with the Assistant Manager who told me I booked an ADA room and I couldn’t just ask for a two double bed room because I messed up. I told her I didn’t that I was given an ADA room because of mold on the ceiling in the room assigned to me when I arrived. I had to show my booking reservations to show I was not lying about my reservation. I finally got a room and was told they would waive the $35 daily service fee that covers Wifi, etc. Well good thing we could never even get on the WiFi because it was so bad. The new room I was assigned to had mold all over the bathroom. See pictures below. After so much trouble and poor service previously in sucked it up and didn’t complain. When you stay at a hotel such as the Crown Plaza it is known for its prestige and cleanliness. I’m paying $1800 for 4 nights for a dirty room with mold. I will never stay at this hotel again. I’ve stayed at LaQuintas that we’re nicer than this and more than half the cost. Don’t pay for a room with a view because the hotel really doesn’t have a direct view of Times Square. You have to lean over and look way down the street to actually see Times Square.

Pros: Location, room

Cons: Extra charges due not listed during reservation request. Beware you will be charged even more after you have reserved

Pros: Breakfast was good

Cons: The second night key card didn't work, waited in a long line to get it re-activated. The clerk Frank's customer service was really bad. He was using his index figer at me, instead of explaining the situation.

Pros: The location was truly awesome once we found it. They are doing some renovations and the signage is horrible. Our UBER driver gave up and dumped us at the corner. We had to muck around until we finally could see the sign way high up on the building.

Cons: The elevators were problematic and we had to use the freight elevator from the 45 floor after waiting 20 minutes. Seemed like a fire hazard. The breakfast spot only offered buffet at $36. I have a 4 oz stomach so it was a really bad deal for me.

Pros: Just the location....

Cons: They didn't want to honor the military rate. It is the first time it has happened. I booked the reservation on-line but in all hotels they don't have any problem adjusting it once you check in. Very unfortunate....I wont come again if they dont solve this for this occassion

Pros: Fantastic location. All the at reception, Bar all very friendly particularly Ana and her colleagues at breakfast.

Cons: The amount of tax that is added onto the hotel bill. I’m sure this is the same for any New York Hotel. Make sure when you book that all taxes are included.