Key West hotels in New Town

Cons: Got a small room that I understood was directed by using Kayak or 3rd party reservation service.

Cons: What I didn't like was the smell of the room and the fact that our first room had a used razor in the bathroom.

Cons: Can’t really think of anything

Cons: Closer to down town

Cons: Our room and elevater could use an update

Cons: The room was quite dark and the toilet didn't work. However, they did send someone immediately to fix it. The room had a musty smell. When the maid came (we were there for 2 days), she only left one washcloth and one handtowel for the two of us.

Cons: Expensive for what you get. No extra incentives are included in what you pay for the rooms it all costs extra. Rather go to the marriott just down the road again.

Cons: food was a bit pricey and left a bit to be desired.

Cons: Our room phone never did work. Internet service was frequently interrupted. BR sink faucets functioned poorly. The White Sox did not win too many games.

Cons: When we arrived at 6pm I was told my room was not ready as I had made my reservation an hour before....so I guess rooms don't get clean unless there are reservations made which made no sense.

Cons: Too pricey for what you get. Don't expect to relax! More of a party hotel. Thought I was back in college but then I couldn't afford it.

Cons: Resort fees

Cons: Late check in time.

Cons: Beach front but can't swim in the water.

Cons: Parking is limited and constrained. The shuttle service to Old Town is inconvenient (2 hour intervals); but free. There are very few local (within walking distance) restaurants. The best, a Fridays, has closed.

Cons: The only negative comment is the parking. The number of parking spaces within the resort does not accommodate the number of guests. We had to park beside a Walgreens which was near the resort but did not have walkable pathways to the resort. We had to walk through trees and climb a slight hill that had no traction.

Cons: 4 pm check in, tile in bathroom was very slippery resulting in a fall, no counter space in the bathroom.

Cons: Did not like the staff. Not friendly at all. Very rude.

Cons: Employees of the restaurant appeared to be uniformily grumpy. Everyone else was really nice. Not really a beach. Waterfront yes but the beach was maybe 20’ wide.

Cons: Parking fees are a bummer. I was sad when I heard the news. Our view from our room was a construction site...so we had to use our imaginations to see what was not there. A security guard made us uncomfortable by staring at my wife's beautiful legs. There needs to be more lizards and iguanas on the property.

Cons: A bit expensive for a single with parking lot view and strange, shared entry foyer. I guess it is meant as a sort of adjoining room for a larger group. Every time the neighbor came and went it was two slammed doors. The doors are real loud when they close. I felt self conscious and tried to close them more quietly when I cam and went.

Cons: expensive poor facilities far from town poor service would never go back.

Cons: Everything was and extra charge ie parking and breakfast. The "beach front" wasn't an ocean access which was very misleading. It was located far from most of the activities in Key West.

Cons: I don't see how this is one of the most luxurious hotels in Key West. I felt completely nickled and dimed on top of the extremely high rate for the hotel. They even try to add on a donation to an undisclosed non-profit -- granted it's a minimal donation but a customer shouldn't have to opt out of giving a donation. The parking fee, considering you're so far from Duval Street, is ridiculous and is over $21 after tax. The set-up of the rooms is far from comfortable -- a common entrance for 2 different rooms, which exacerbates the noise made by your neighbor. Furthermore, so much construction was going on around the hotel that we literally had to call the hotel to find out how to enter -- they then informed us that we had to enter through Hyatt's parking lot. I honestly couldn't wait to check out, but even that caused problems as they made me wait in line for 25 min since they only had one person working the desk. Steer clear of this hotel.

Cons: The room wasy way overpriced considering there was no view and that it was not a suite.

Cons: Due to an event in Key West we payed 400$/night which was very expensive! The hotel would have been a great value for 150-200$/night

Cons: You have to pay for parking, the beach is nothing to rave about and mostly weeds and grass. The rooms are super tiny. To me the hotel seems appropriate as a 3 star hotel. Good thing is close to downtown and shopping.

Cons: no windows really ugly far from town too expensive far better options

Cons: $20 parking per night

Cons: Parking was in a ground level garage; our room was on the 4th floor.

Cons: We stayed in a standard king room, which was fine size for us (without cooking amenities). What wasn't great was that it was on 1st floor which is adjacent to N. Roosevelt Blvd, so the traffic can be loud and wake you up.

Cons: They are doing construction and cutting tile 9 to 5 during the week next to the pool. Should have let us know in Advance. Could not use pool or beach all day due to noise

Cons: Nothing it was perfect

Cons: N/A

Cons: The staff was a bit rude when we checked in but got better as the stay went on!

Cons: We had two experiences with roaches. We advised the front desk each time. One said she would make a note of it the other person at the desk took several minutes to explain the habits of Palmetto bugs in the warm weather. No one came to spray or check on the room. Breakfast could have a little bit more variety.

Cons: The fitness room needs updating. Limited equipment. There was also a hidden fee not disclosed when booking - a $25/night "destination/amenity fee". That included 2 drinks per day at the bar, pool towels and shuttle transportation to the downtown area of key west. Perhaps that was useful to some travelers but it was a waste of $50 for the 2 nights we spent there as we did not use the pool, bar or the shuttle. Sneaky, hidden fees like that should be disclosed when booking.

Cons: Our room smelled slightly of cigarette smoke, and the shower had mildew in some of the grout. The sink area allowed a pool of water to collect due to an uneven surface. The walls are quite thin. The rooms were lacking in lighting. Being one of two Fairfield locations in Key West, it's the farther from the major attractions. Overall, small gripes. I would certainly stay here again

Cons: Distance from Duval...although relatively short 10 min drive.

Cons: Parking and breakfast seating. The parking spaces are MUCH too thin, creating many spaces which were unparkable as others had parked over both side lines. This made my 8 month pregnant wife have to walk from the opposite side of the hotel in the only parking spot available. Also, at 9:00 am, there is not enough tables for the amount of people eating breakfast. We had to sit in the lobby to eat our breakfast. These two things made our stay less enjoyable.

Cons: Entrance on curved road. Dangerous entry/egress

Cons: No thing to report.

Cons: The staff wasn't too helpful, it could have been because it wasn't directly booked with them but through Kayak. I wanted to change from a king size bed to a two bed room but they said they were sold out. However, when walking around the hotel around 11PM I saw plenty of empty rooms with two beds. In addition, I got (initially) charged for drinks I did not have at the pool. Overall it's okay, but I wouldn't book there again unless it was my only option.

Cons: Free parking or breakfast would have been nice.

Cons: Twenty dollar cab ride to Duval Street or twenty dollars for shuttle. Hotel is on main road at the entrance to Key West. Road noise was distracting and sleep disruptive from motorcycles and first responders. Long wait for check in not well staffed or prepared with prepaid customers paperwork.

Cons: The price was a bit high so I expected at least to have complementary continental breakfast that other less expensive hotel offered. Extremely late check in and early check out. Check in does not start until 4:00pm.

Cons: Wile the pool was open, the outdoor bar and hot tub was closed due to a car running off the road and hitting it. That was unavoidable on the hotel’s part of course bat we were told it had happened there months previously. No work had been done on it and the indoor bar did not open until 4 or 5 depending on the day. The only alcoholic beverages available were canned mixed drinks and beer available in the little shop the have. We like spending the day at the pool and going out at night so that was a disappointment. The biggest issue is the location. We knew that when we booked it with Hilton Honor points. Unfortunately, it was more inconvenient than we thought. There is a shuttle that was free at the time we were there although signs said $19.95 a day unlimited. The shuttle was usually full goin and we were dropped off several blocks from Duval and Mallory square although there were shops and restaurants at the location. We used it to go downtown but used Lyft to come back because of the drop off / pick up location. So, my low rating is for the relatively high price compared to the location.

Cons: Houskeeping could have been a little better. First Day, our towels were not changed, which was alright. But we didn't get wash cloths. Also had to use Hand Towel as a bath mat.

Cons: The hotel is far from town. This was our first time to Key West so we didn’t realize that there is only one area that stuff happens, so we might as well have been out in the suburbs. Also the mattress and pillows were not very comfortable. The pool is constantly out of towels. So that is a bit disappointing.

Cons: Housekeeping

Cons: The elevator was slower than snails snot. You can see the water around all the obstructions. But it is not the Oceanview, it is water but not the ocean. Way overpriced

Cons: Needed more pool chairs.

Cons: The resort fee is too expensive. The shuttle does not run @ all times. A cab cost about $16 to get to Duval St. There were never enough towels in the room; however, when we called, housekeeping did bring more towels within 30 minutes. The room was much smaller than it looked from the pictures on the website. Next time I will also choose to stay closer to Old Town.

Cons: No Resturant on site

Cons: the breakfast wasn't what we expected. and the restaurant after hours, that we had to walk to the "next door restaurant" to get the food.

Cons: Being fairly new, the first room we were provided had issues with the barn door for the bathroom where it wouldn't close. We had paid for a ocean view and we're given a room where the elevator block the view. The front desk was able to give us another room but couldn't provide us then with the size bed we had requested since we were there for multiple nights. The new room was clean and similarly put together but the barn door still on occasion would get stuck. Leaving one of us trapted temporary in the bathroom. The second downfall which really has to do with the location is it is right there upon entering key west so if you request a ocean view room, you're going to hear the traffic coming and going.