Edinburgh inns

Pros: Loved the overall smell of the hotel and how each room had its own unique theme. We were in the Marble Room and absolutely loved the design! Extremely comfy bed and fantastic shower. Would definitely stay here again.

Cons: There was nothing we didn’t like!

Pros: It was modern and stylish. The bed was huge and comfy!

Cons: Nothing! Was all great.

Pros: The room decor was stunning. Loved the under floor heating in the bathroom. Snacks provided daily in the room. Mark was extremely helpful. Thank you.

Pros: Stylish and very comfortable, and in a great location in the heart of Morningside. Appreciated the complimentary drink next door at the historic Canny Man pub.

Cons: All was good

Pros: Lovely room lovely people lovely bar/resto. Definitely one to recommend!

Pros: Excellent Location. Bed comfortable. Free drink in Canny Man’s.

Cons: No breakfast included.

Pros: Comfortable bed Staff were very helpful

Cons: Snack room was in need of attention. Private patio flowers could use some TLC.

Pros: Fantastic location Superlingsize bed Bus stop outside Parking available Theres a snack room full of treats which was an added bonus..all complimentary Clean sheets fresh towels daily Iron too

Cons: The wife is a little poor but that's minor

Pros: A lovely room, incredibly clean, and stocked with snacks, drinks and toiletries. Would recommend!

Pros: Very warm welcome from the staff who showed us to our room; the courtesy bar with snack and extra coffee; fresh milk was a lovely touch; as was the free welcome drink in the bar next door.

Cons: I can’t fault the property in any way.

Pros: Great location, the room was amazing for the price, staff were really friendly & I got a free pint on check in ...whats not to like?

Cons: The housekeeping woke me up shouting about having hangovers outside my room ....

Pros: Great location fantastic room

Cons: Bed and pillows were a bit too firm

Pros: The breakfasts were great, the cleanliness and layout of the room was great, the brownies upon checking-in were great......the staff were ALL wonderful.

Cons: The pillows were thin and hard......the bed was very hard (like a futon). One of the housekeeping staff brought us 2 softer pillows that were much better for our next 3 nights. We had to walk up 6 flights of stairs to get to our room, but we got used to it. Bring ear plugs. There is the ocassional ambulance or partiers emptying out of the hotel next door at 3 AM and being really loud until they finally dispersed. Otherwise it's pretty quiet. We heard our neighbors coming in to the common foyer, but we did not hear them anymore once they were inside their rooms.

Pros: Brilliant location and considering the proximity to the street you would think it would be noisy but they have brilliant sound proofing! Stunning room, lots of lovely touches and very spacious.

Cons: Wasn’t clear what was included or what was extra when it came to the ‘mini bar’ aka cupboard or brownies that were left on the desk.... coffee pods weren’t labelled so we weren’t sure what was decaf milk or coffee

Pros: Lovely unique property

Cons: Really bid bed for smallish room

Pros: Good location

Cons: Breakfast tea Breakfast served on a cold plate

Pros: Loved everything related to the accommodation.

Cons: The staff in the bar at breakfast following the last night told me that diary free porridge was not possible, despite me having that only two days earlier. We’re quite rude about it and made no attempts to try to solve the problem.

Pros: Location perfect

Cons: Nothing

Pros: If you like being in the middle of the tourist trap it is perfect.

Cons: They are not up front about several things. First there is no one at the place to handle problems. No desk, no phone number. Just email. Second, the only way to get in is by a terrible spiral stone staircase, so it is very hard to get large suitcases up. Third, when I made the reservation they immediately charged me and sent an email that I would be on the fourth floor. I made the reservation months in advance and I asked them to move me to a lower floor. They said they couldn't, but if they could it would cost 10 euros. Very hard to deal with. They also do not provide maid service unless you pay another 17 euros per day! Also no place to leave your luggage because its not a hotel. Finally, I have some serious concerns about the integrity of the apartments. The floors slope and there is serious signs of cracking and sag. At these prices, you are far better booking elsewhere!

Pros: Very nice, good value for money. Nice location. Thank you.

Cons: Everything was OK.

Pros: Great central location, clean & comfortable inside with good amenities.

Cons: Nothing only the stairs challenging with luggage.

Pros: Brilliant location.

Cons: There was no dressing table or mirror in the room apart from above the bed which was hard to dry and style your hair. The quilt was very old and thin and the room was cold due to old windows. We were on he fourth floor which was really difficult to climb with luggage

Pros: Fantastic location, very close to Edinburgh castle.

Cons: The access was via lots of steep stone stairs with minimal handrails. Considering the cost, the room was very basic. The bed was comfortable but the sofa bed was very poor quality. The sheets and duvet were very old and worn with just one pillow each. Lastly, there is no furniture in the room for storing clothes, no wardrobe or drawers at all, very odd. The standards were more in line with a backpackers, extremely overpriced.

Pros: Location in the middle of Old Town was perfect. Rooms and bathroom were clean and nice. Bed was good. Apartment was easy to find because we got good instructions.

Cons: Bathroom was cold (owner promised to bring new heater but it was a little late for us). Other rooms were warm. Table or shelf space I needed more in every room. Livingroom was noisy at night time but bedroom was quiet.

Pros: Location is fantastic

Cons: Basic bed linen. Shower slow and Luke warm. A bit scruffy

Pros: The bed was comfy, it was exactly what we needed for a 1 night stay and the staff were very friendly.

Pros: Breakfast was gorgeous crispy bacon lovely eggs lots of tea and toast

Cons: Disappointed they had no decaf tea or coffee (provided my own)

Pros: Great restaurant with good menu, busy bar with sports tv, great bus service into Centre of Edinburgh. Rooms very clean but do need updating ( been told an update 2020 ) also doggie friendly.

Cons: Our room was cool because the heating was on a time.

Pros: The staff were amazing, so helpful and polite. The food was great, and for the price it was amazing. Mike the manager was so helpful with were to go for transport, and always greeted us when we saw him.

Cons: Only thing wrong with the front door wouldn’t open. But the staff came down to help us at 1 in the morning. Couldn’t ask for more help !

Pros: Friendly staff very reasonable and a great breakfast.

Pros: Food was great and breakfast was tasty, Room was basic but met my needs as was just needing somewhere to stay for the night.

Cons: there was nothing that stood out that i didnt like, it was a very pleasant stay. Staff were helpful and food tasty.

Pros: Extra large comfy bed in large room with fluffy towels. Good breakfast until 10am at weekends and good food in bar and restaurant in the evening. Staff all friendly with attention to detail.

Cons: If I was being really picky the sign outside swang around so was noisy at night time

Pros: The proximity to Murrayfield Stadium

Cons: No toiletries in the bathroom

Pros: Cosy comfortable pub/restaurant. All staff polite and friendly. Room was great with a huge comfortable bed. All amenities catered for.

Cons: The only thing that I didnt like and this is being picky, is that the bathroom is very dated and could do with an upgrade. It also had a 'funky' smell to it. But this is just being picky.

Pros: The greeting we got was lovely

Cons: The room was clean but a little small and closed in. No proper milk for a cup of tea. Only coffee whitener. No non slip mats in the bathroom.

Pros: price and location good for what we required.

Cons: larger bathroom.

Pros: this was a great B * B. We were met at the door by a very nice young man and efficiently shown to our room. The room was very comfortable. Location was excellent, as we were able to walk to everything we wanted to see.

Cons: The shower was just barely warm.

Pros: Staff was very friendly, close to the city centre. Good value for money

Cons: Very small bathroom, breakfast from 9 so if you want an early start it’s a bit late. No hot breakfast

Pros: - We stayed for 2 nights and they clean the room everyday. -Breakfast was Continental and the quality of the products was good. Advice, if you miss something in the breakfast let them know it.

Cons: - The firts night we had to stay without hot water and no heating system. The second night they had to provide us a electrical heater. They should understand that travellers from other sides of the world may be cold at 10-12 degrees even if they dont. - We asked for a baby cot and the first night was busy. The second night they told us that was broken for the night before. I strongly believe they lied to us both nights because I ask them to see the “broken coat” second night and I still waiting for it!

Pros: This was the perfect place to stay. Close enough to walk to the city center. Great food in this part of town as well. The owner is so great and offered suggestions for places to eat. She was very accommodating and hospitable. Breakfast was fantastic with eggs, mushrooms, tomatoes, toast and jams, ect. Tea or coffee served. Would stay here again.

Cons: The Stairs are challenging to navigate.

Pros: The location was excellent, and it was the only good thing about the hotel. There are shops and restaurants just at the end of the road, and it's not too long a walk to get to the central areas of the city. The person at reception was friendly.

Cons: Normally I don't mind if the place I'm staying at is not perfect, and I'm prepared to ignore a few shortcomings. However, there was just too many things added up that I just could not ignore anymore, and I feel that the photographs are very misleading, as that is not the condition the hotel is at the moment. I might not have minded if it had been very cheap, but for the money we paid we were expecting at least a decent place to stay. 1) Hot water completely run out in the middle of my shower. Not being able to have a hot shower after 6 hours of driving across the country and having to shower with cold water was not the way I wanted to start my weekend in Edinburgh. 2) The shower was mouldy. I'm talking about mould on the electric shower dial and the shower hose (which was also leaking even when shower was not working). 3) During the day the room was freezing cold and there was no way of turning the heating on. 4) At breakfast there was not enough of anything, certainly not enough for everyone to have a bit of everything. No one was checking or replenishing anything. No water available. The table setting was inconsistent, there were plates and cups missing, only two plates had napkins on them (no other napkins available anywhere). 5) We had only 3 sachets of coffee in our room (meaning we could either have coffee in the evening we arrived OR the next morning, not both..). Our dirty coffee cups were not replaced the following day, and the coffees were not replenished. 6) We didn't have towels in the room when we arrived. When I asked for some towels we were given one large towel each, no hand/hair towel, no bathroom mat. 7) There was the previous guests' paperwork and used tourist leaflets left in the top drawer of our bedside table (obviously noone is checking the room properly). 8) The pipes in the bathroom are very noisy (sound like a jackhammer).